← Back to articles

HMRC's Safe Harbour for Agents Covers Filing, and Only Filing

Haroon Subhani · 14 November 2026 · 5 min read

HMRC's Safe Harbour for Agents Covers Filing, and Only Filing

Sooner or later a new client arrives already inside something. A contractor-pay firm or a previous adviser set it up, and the client wants the books done and the return filed. HMRC's guidance on the prohibition of promotion regime, published 30 October 2026, says whether I can file that return (HMRC, 2026). The answer is yes, on conditions that leave the books outside it, and I don't plan to rely on them.

TL;DR: HMRC says filing a return built on figures from a prohibited scheme isn't promotion, if filing is all you do and you're unconnected to the promoter. That comfort comes from guidance, not the Act. Accounts work and advice sit outside it, and an accountant's advice gets no legal advice privilege. I'd rather ask at onboarding.

What does the guidance let an agent do?

Since May 2026, section 159 of the Finance Act 2026 has made it unlawful to promote two kinds of arrangement: those marketed for a tax advantage with no realistic prospect of delivering it, and those HMRC specifies in regulations (Finance Act 2026, s159). Civil penalties reach £1 million plus £5,000 per participant (s162), and the criminal offence carries up to two years' imprisonment on indictment (s163).

The guidance says filing a return built on such figures isn't promotion, if filing is the agent's sole action and the agent isn't related to the promoter or any other party involved, in any way.

Why is the filing carve-out weaker than it looks?

Because it isn't in the Act. Section 160(2) gives two statutory exits: supplying goods or services on commercial terms when you don't know, and couldn't reasonably be expected to know, they're feeding a prohibited scheme, and giving legally privileged advice (s160). Nothing about returns. The filing comfort is HMRC's reading.

And "sole action" describes almost no engagement I'd take on. I prepare the accounts, advise on the figures and chase the paperwork.

None of that is automatically promotion, but it falls outside the carve-out and gets tested against section 160(1)(c), which catches anyone who "organises or manages any aspect" of arrangements someone else implemented. Nobody knows yet where that line sits.

The commercial-services exit rewards not knowing, and onboarding is exactly where I find out. I'll take the knowledge. "Couldn't reasonably be expected to know" is unlikely to cover an accountant who chose not to look.

Does privilege protect an accountant's advice?

Rarely. HMRC's privilege guidance, published 23 October 2026, restates the Supreme Court in Prudential [2013] UKSC 1: legal advice privilege doesn't extend to advice from professionals other than lawyers, even where it's legal advice they're qualified to give (HMRC, 2026).

HMRC accepts litigation privilege may apply once litigation is in contemplation, which isn't onboarding. So the section 160(2)(b) exit mostly helps the tax barrister. Ordinary advice on my letterhead doesn't get it.

What HMRC's penalty example shows

Company A, an employment business, had 130 participants at the breach and an estimated £50,000 of fees afterwards. Against a £1,650,000 maximum, the officer set £615,000, roughly 12 times the fees (HMRC, 2026).

HMRC weighed its engagement and plan to close the arrangements. Not knowing the law counted for nothing, and no warning letter came first, though the Act gives 30 days to make representations before a penalty is imposed. Company A is an illustration, not a real case. HMRC also says criminal investigation is reserved for cases where it needs to send "a strong deterrent message", or where only a criminal sanction is appropriate.

Most of my readers will never meet this

Avoidance was £0.8 billion in 2024-25, 1% of the tax gap (HMRC, 2026), and carelessness and error drive far more of it. The Economic Secretary told MPs the clauses are "very much not intended to be directed against legitimate tax advisers" who work to a high professional standard and make a genuine mistake in good faith.

Still, three things go into my onboarding, each costing minutes. A direct question about any tax arrangement already in place, alongside the handover read I do before saying yes. A file note on any engagement that touches one, recording what I did and didn't do.

And no introducer fee from anyone selling a tax result, because a referral fee is a relationship. A live scheme without a specialist handling the exit joins the jobs I won't take on.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I file a tax return for a client in a tax avoidance scheme?

HMRC's guidance says yes, if filing is the only thing you do and you have no link to the promoter or anyone else involved. That's guidance rather than statute, so note what you did and didn't do.

Do the 2026 rules catch ordinary tax planning?

No. They target marketed schemes with no realistic prospect of working, or types named in HMRC regulations. Choosing between salary and dividends, claiming capital allowances or making pension contributions isn't that.

What should I do if I think I've promoted a scheme?

Stop, and take specialist legal advice before you speak to HMRC. Section 162(4) makes cooperation, and whether the breach continued over an extended period, factors in setting the penalty, so stopping early counts.


If you're inside an arrangement someone sold you, get in touch. I'll go through the paperwork and tell you straight whether it needs a specialist.

Share this article

© 2026 Haroon Subhani · theaccntnt.com · Terms · Privacy

ACCA · CertIFR · MSc · BSc · Xero Specialist · QuickBooks ProAdvisor