Most of the sole traders and landlords I work with run their year around two dates, 31 January and 31 July. The tax money sits in a separate savings account until one of them arrives, earning a little interest while it waits. On 28 October HMRC confirmed that rhythm ends for anyone on payments on account. From April 2029, the default becomes automated payments during the tax year itself (HMRC summary of responses, 2026).
I read the response expecting the professional bodies to have won. They did, on the narrow point. On the bigger one they lost, and more people are in scope now than when the consultation opened.
TL;DR: From April 2029, people who make Self Assessment payments on account pay during the tax year, automated by default, for example by Direct Debit. PAYE collection became optional, but the scope widened to about 3 million people. The bill itself doesn't change. The gap between earning and paying shrinks, and the 2029-30 transition year looks expensive.
What did HMRC actually decide?
Self Assessment taxpayers liable to payments on account will make in-year payments towards their bill from April 2029, automated by default. HMRC's factsheet says payments will be automated "for example by Direct Debit", so treat Direct Debit as the likely method rather than a confirmed sole one (HMRC factsheet, 2026). Anyone with enough PAYE income (from a job or a pension, for example) can choose to pay through their tax code instead.
The amount owed doesn't move. The factsheet says no one will see any change to their tax liability, and the return deadline stays at 31 January. Almost everything a client would ask next is still open: how often payments fall, how the forecast is built, what happens when income drops, and the penalty and interest rules for a missed instalment. HMRC says it'll set out the frequency, timing, penalties and transition next year. The rest it will only "consider", and nothing is legislated yet.
Who won the consultation?
The respondents, on the point they actually argued. The Budget 2025 plan would have pushed Self Assessment payments for people with enough PAYE income through their payslip every pay period, starting with 2029-30. HMRC estimated about 2.1 million people fell within it (HMRC consultation, 2026).
HMRC received 3,630 written responses, mostly from the self-employed and small businesses, and most opposed mandatory PAYE collection. So the mandate went. In its place, the government extended in-year payments to everyone liable to payments on account, "to create a level playing field". That's around 3 million of the 12 million people who file a return (HMRC factsheet, 2026).
HMRC's motive is in its own figures: around one in five Self Assessment bills is paid late. Collecting earlier and automatically is the fix it chose. My read for anyone who thinks the lobbying killed this: it made PAYE optional for one group and in-year payment the default for a bigger one.
The 22-month float is being called in
The current timetable has quietly been part of how small businesses fund themselves. HMRC's consultation says that for someone who starts trading at the very start of a tax year, it's currently up to 22 months before they pay the tax due. For an established sole trader, the tax on income earned in April 2029 is paid in three pieces under today's rules: 31 January 2030, 31 July 2030, and any balance on 31 January 2031.
In finance terms that lag is a float, an interest-free loan from HMRC for as long as you pay by the due date. Across the £48 billion of Self Assessment income tax collected in 2024-25, it's a large one. The Budget 2025 costing of the original PAYE plan shows the shape: £85 million in 2028-29, £605 million in 2029-30, then £235 million in 2030-31. A permanent tax rise would show steady numbers. A spike that falls away is what a timing change looks like, where the Exchequer gets the cash earlier once. Those figures cover the PAYE-only design and will be re-costed, but the pattern is the point.
What does the 2029-30 transition year cost?
Potentially half a year's tax, once. HMRC hasn't said how the transition will work. The consultation's template for the PAYE group was that in 2029-30 people would pay the new in-year instalments and also settle what's left of 2028-29 under the old rules. KPMG flagged the same overlap in its Budget commentary (KPMG, 2026), and respondents raised it too.
An illustration, assuming a flat £12,000 annual bill and that template. Between 6 April 2029 and 5 April 2030, today's rules would collect £6,000 on 31 July 2029 (the second payment on account for 2028-29) and £6,000 on 31 January 2030 (the first for 2029-30). With flat income there's no balancing payment, so that's £12,000.
Under the new default, the July 2029 £6,000 still falls due, plus roughly £12,000 of in-year payments towards 2029-30. That's £18,000 in the same twelve months. Same tax overall, a lot more cash out of the door in one year.
What I'd do before April 2029
Start treating the tax pot as money already spent. If you keep a separate tax savings account, fund it every month from now on rather than in a rush before January, and plan for the 2029-30 year needing about an extra half-year of tax put aside. HMRC plans web and app tools in 2028 that let you estimate your liability, make voluntary payments and track them against the forecast. I'd use that year as a rehearsal.
For lumpy income, the forecast is where it hurts. Payments will rest on an estimate, and HMRC has only said it will consider how people update that forecast when their income changes. The consultation asked whether Making Tax Digital quarterly updates should feed that forecast, which matters for anyone already filing quarterly under MTD for Income Tax. Keep the quarterly records clean enough to argue a forecast down.
Then mind the stack. From April 2029 businesses will also need a Direct Debit set up for VAT and PAYE return payments unless exempt, which HMRC will use to collect anything unpaid at the due date (HMRC, 2026), following the proposal covered in August. Mandatory e-invoicing for VAT-registered businesses starts on 1 April 2029 too (HMRC e-invoicing roadmap, 2026). That's a lot of change to one month. The wider Budget 2026 round-up has the measures that land sooner.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will Self Assessment payments on account change in 2029?
Yes. From April 2029, if you're liable to payments on account you'll pay towards the current year's bill during that year, automated by default, instead of the two fixed payments on 31 January and 31 July. Today you're in the regime if last year's Self Assessment bill was £1,000 or more and less than 80% of your total tax for that year was collected at source, for example through PAYE.
Do I have to pay my Self Assessment tax by Direct Debit from April 2029?
HMRC's wording is automated payments "for example by Direct Debit", so Direct Debit is the likely route but it isn't confirmed as the only one. The response doesn't say whether you can opt out of automated payment. Expect detail in 2027.
Can I choose to pay my Self Assessment bill through PAYE?
Yes, if you have enough PAYE income from employment or a private pension. It's an opt-in, not a requirement. HMRC hasn't said what counts as enough, though the current rule caps PAYE collection at 50% of your pay in any pay period.
Will the in-year payments be monthly?
Nobody knows yet. The consultation used monthly and quarterly as examples, but the government says frequency and timing will be set out next year. I'd plan your savings monthly regardless.
What happens if I miss an in-year payment?
That's undecided. Penalties and interest for the new payments are on HMRC's list of things to set out next year, alongside safeguards for people in financial difficulty. Until 2029, today's late payment rules apply to the January and July dates.
If your income is uneven and you want to work out what 2029-30 does to your cash, get in touch. I'm happy to run your last two returns through the new timetable with you.
