← Back to articles

HMRC's Manual Says You Prove You Weren't Careless. Push Back

Haroon Subhani · 22 November 2026 · 8 min read

HMRC's Manual Says You Prove You Weren't Careless. Push Back

EM3259 is a short page in HMRC's Enquiry Manual, and it's the one I'd put in front of an officer who assesses a year that's already out of ordinary time. On 16 November HMRC rewrote it. The sentence I'd have quoted is gone, and the one replacing it gives a very different answer about who has to prove what.

If you get a letter this winter for 2020-21 or 2021-22, this is the guidance the officer works from. So it's worth knowing what it now says, and where it overreaches.

TL;DR: HMRC's manual now says once an officer makes a prima facie case of carelessness, the assessment is presumed valid and you must prove you weren't careless. The tribunals put the burden of proving carelessness on HMRC, and a prima facie case can be answered. Don't concede it. Appeal inside 30 days and make HMRC show its case year by year.

What did HMRC change on 16 November?

The page on who proves behaviour for extended time limit assessments. The January 2026 version told officers that at tribunal "HMRC will need to demonstrate that the alleged behaviour is sufficiently serious to support the assessment", and that the onus would normally revert to the taxpayer "if they are appealing against the amount of the assessment" (Enquiry Manual EM3259, archived January 2026).

The new version says HMRC's initial burden is "to establish a prima facie case that a relevant condition is met", meaning a case that looks right on its face until somebody answers it.

After that, "the assessment is presumed to be valid. The burden then shifts to the taxpayer to demonstrate that the relevant behaviour did not occur or that the behaviour did not bring about the loss of tax" (EM3259, 2026). The change note calls this "updated to reflect current practice" (Enquiry Manual updates, 2026).

The old page shifted the burden on how much. The new one shifts it on whether you were careless at all. That's a different question, and the one that decides whether the year can be assessed.

Does the manual change the law?

No. A manual tells officers how HMRC sees things; the tribunals decide who proves what.

In Burgess and Brimheath the Upper Tribunal held that HMRC "had the duty of establishing their case on both the competence and time limit issues. The burden of proof lay on them in each of those respects" (Burgess v HMRC [2015] UKUT 578 (TCC), para 43). In March this year, in a case HMRC lost, the Upper Tribunal called it "uncontentious" that the burden "is first on HMRC to show the discovery assessment is valid", with the taxpayer then showing the amount is excessive (HMRC v Harte [2026] UKUT 112 (TCC), para 46).

HMRC's own Compliance Handbook still says: "The onus of proof of careless or deliberate behaviour is on HMRC" (CH54300, 2026). It even sends the reader to EM3259 for more, so HMRC's two manuals now pull in different directions on the same question.

So where does HMRC's new wording come from?

From real case law, read generously. In Mullens the Upper Tribunal summarised Hudson v Humbles (1965): if HMRC shows "a prima facie case of income tax not being paid as a result of fraud or wilful default which the taxpayer did not satisfactorily answer", its burden is discharged and the burden "then shifted to the taxpayer to show why the assessment was incorrect" (Mullens v HMRC [2023] UKUT 244 (TCC), para 48).

Two things matter there. The prima facie case has to go unanswered, so you get to answer it. And what shifts is the job of showing the assessment is wrong, which the same judgment ties to the amount: once the assessment is shown to be competent, "it was for the taxpayer to displace the amount of tax assessed" (para 53).

My reading: HMRC's opening bar is genuinely low, and the new EM3259 is right about that. It goes further than the cases when it frames disproving carelessness itself, rather than answering HMRC's case or the amount, as your job.

Why does this matter right now?

Because of where the time limits fall this winter. HMRC normally has 4 years from the end of a tax year to assess (TMA 1970 s34), extended to 6 where the loss was brought about carelessly and 20 where it was deliberate (TMA 1970 s36, 2026). Companies have the same 4, 6 and 20 years under Schedule 18 Finance Act 1998, counted from the end of the accounting period.

The ordinary 4-year window for 2021-22 shut on 5 April 2026. The 6-year window for 2020-21 shuts on 5 April 2027. So an income tax assessment for either year needs an extended time limit, which for most people means HMRC alleging carelessness.

Assessments raised against a closing time limit tend to get called "protective", which is the second change. EM3258 now tells officers to avoid the word, because it gives "the impression that it does not meet the basic conditions for a discovery assessment and invite[s] unwarranted challenges" (EM3258, 2026). A client who hears "protective" could easily put the letter in a drawer. It's a real assessment, with a real 30-day appeal clock.

What I'd do when the letter arrives

Diary the 30 days first. An appeal has to be given in writing within 30 days of the notice of assessment (TMA 1970 s31A, 2026). Miss it and you need HMRC's agreement or the tribunal's permission to appeal late. I've written before about how final a withdrawn tax appeal can be, and a missed deadline isn't much kinder.

Then I'd appeal, and ask for postponement in the same letter. Without it the tax is due as if there were no appeal (TMA 1970 s55, 2026).

In the appeal I'd ask HMRC to set out its behaviour case for each year and each error. Harte matters here: HMRC argued that one culpable error validated the whole assessment and its longer time limit, and lost. You can show that an error made despite reasonable care falls outside the assessment, even if another error in the same year stays in.

A new page added on 18 November, EM3295, adds that HMRC can't widen an assessment on appeal beyond what the officer discovered, though it can bring new reasons to defend it. Only then would I argue about the amount.

Why your records decide this, not the manual

A low opening bar means the first real evidence often has to come from you. If HMRC's case is "the figure was wrong and nobody can explain why", the answer is the email where you asked your accountant, the reconciliation you kept, the note of why you treated something the way you did.

The risk is real. Failure to take reasonable care is the biggest behavioural slice of the UK tax gap at 35%, and small businesses make up 62% of a provisional gap estimated at £59.2 billion, or 6.4%, for 2024-25 (HMRC, 2026). HMRC brought in a record £50.2 billion of compliance yield in 2025-26 (HMRC annual report, 2026). That's the gap HMRC is trying to close, so careless is where most of these arguments will happen.

I've written about where HMRC draws the line between careless, reckless and criminal, and about the draft duty to correct. This rewrite sits underneath both, because it decides who does the proving.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who has to prove carelessness if HMRC assesses an old tax year?

HMRC, first. The Upper Tribunal has held that the burden on the time-limit conditions lies on HMRC, and HMRC's Compliance Handbook agrees. Answer any prima facie case with evidence and make HMRC prove carelessness on the balance of probabilities.

How far back can HMRC go if it says I was careless?

Six years from the end of the tax year for income tax and capital gains tax, or six years from the end of the accounting period for a company. The ordinary limit is four years and the deliberate limit is twenty. For 2020-21, the careless window closes on 5 April 2027.

What is a "protective" assessment and do I have to appeal it?

It's an informal name for an assessment raised to stop a time limit running out while HMRC is still checking. HMRC has now told officers to stop using the word. Whatever it's called, it's a real assessment, and if you don't appeal within 30 days it can stand.

Do I have to pay while I appeal?

Yes, unless you apply to postpone it. Under section 55 TMA 1970 the tax is due as if there were no appeal, so ask to postpone the disputed amount in the appeal letter.


If an assessment for an old year has landed, or you think one might before April, get in touch. I'm happy to read the letter with you and work out what HMRC has to prove before you do.

Share this article

© 2026 Haroon Subhani · theaccntnt.com · Terms · Privacy

ACCA · CertIFR · MSc · BSc · Xero Specialist · QuickBooks ProAdvisor